Think Your HSA Is Safe? Think AGAIN.

Health Savings Account fees could cost you over $26,000 in lost wealth if you don’t understand the hidden impact of investment charges.

At a Glance

  • HSAs offer triple tax advantages: tax-free contributions, growth, and qualified withdrawals
  • 2025 contribution limits are $4,300 for individuals and $8,550 for families, plus $1,000 catch-up for those 55+
  • Fee structures vary dramatically between providers – capped fees can save nearly $27,000 over 30 years compared to percentage-based fees
  • You can establish an HSA outside your employer’s offering to potentially access better investment options and lower fees
  • Millennial millionaires are maximizing HSA contributions and letting funds grow tax-free for retirement

The Triple Tax Advantage That’s Often Overlooked

Health Savings Accounts stand alone in America’s tax code as the only vehicle offering a triple tax advantage. Contributions are tax-deductible, growth compounds tax-free, and withdrawals for qualified medical expenses remain untaxed.

These powerful benefits make HSAs an increasingly important component in comprehensive financial planning, especially for Americans planning for retirement healthcare costs. Paired exclusively with high-deductible health plans (HDHPs), HSAs allow account holders to accumulate funds over time rather than use them for immediate medical expenses.

Unlike Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs), HSAs are owned by the individual rather than the employer, meaning the funds roll over year after year and follow you when changing jobs. This portability creates a significant opportunity for long-term wealth accumulation, provided account holders understand how to maximize their investment potential while minimizing fees. For 2025, contribution limits have increased to $4,300 for single coverage and $8,550 for family coverage, with an additional $1,000 catch-up contribution available for those 55 and older.

The Hidden Cost of HSA Investment Fees

While many Americans understand the basic tax benefits of HSAs, fewer recognize how dramatically different fee structures can impact long-term wealth accumulation. A detailed analysis comparing two common HSA fee structures revealed that over a 30-year investment horizon, the difference in fees alone could amount to nearly $27,000 in lost wealth. This stark difference emerged when comparing an HSA with a 0.40% annual fee capped at $10 monthly versus one charging an uncapped 0.60% fee billed quarterly.

The fee disparity becomes particularly pronounced as account balances grow over time. A capped fee structure becomes increasingly advantageous as your HSA balance increases, while percentage-based fees continue taking larger bites from your growing nest egg. Beyond the primary investment fees, account holders should also be vigilant about additional charges that may not be immediately apparent, including monthly maintenance fees, transfer fees, account closing costs, and the expense ratios within the mutual funds or ETFs offered in the HSA investment platform.

Freedom to Choose Your Own HSA Provider

Many Americans don’t realize they have the freedom to establish an HSA with any provider they choose, not just the one offered by their employer. While employer-sponsored HSA contributions made through payroll deductions offer the additional benefit of avoiding FICA taxes (7.65% for most workers), this advantage only applies to income below the Social Security wage base. For higher-income earners or those seeking better investment options, establishing an independent HSA may provide significant long-term advantages through lower fees and superior investment choices.

“You can go anywhere you want, set up your own HSA account, make your own contributions to it, and deduct it on your tax returns,” he said. “I just do an electronic transfer once a year to make my annual contribution. I make sure it’s listed on my tax return because it doesn’t flow through my W-2, so I have to deduct it on my tax returns.”

After age 65, HSAs transform into powerful retirement vehicles. While qualified medical expenses remain tax-free withdrawals at any age, the 20% penalty for non-medical withdrawals disappears at 65, effectively making an HSA function similarly to a traditional IRA for non-medical expenses (withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income but face no additional penalties). This flexibility, combined with America’s consistently rising healthcare costs in retirement, makes HSAs an increasingly important component of conservative retirement planning.

Strategic Considerations for HSA Maximization

For Americans with high-deductible health plans who can afford to cover current medical expenses out-of-pocket, maximizing HSA contributions and allowing those funds to grow tax-free represents a prudent long-term strategy. Unlike most retirement accounts, HSAs have no required minimum distributions (RMDs), meaning the funds can continue growing tax-free indefinitely. This feature makes HSAs particularly valuable for passing wealth to heirs, though inherited HSAs lose their tax-advantaged status for non-spouse beneficiaries.

Savvy HSA owners should review their provider’s fee structure and investment options annually, much as they would review their other retirement accounts. With the significant disparity in quality among HSA providers, simply accepting an employer’s default option without investigation could potentially cost thousands in unnecessary fees over a lifetime. For many Americans approaching retirement, consulting with a financial advisor who understands both the tax implications and investment opportunities within HSAs can help maximize this uniquely advantaged account type for both current healthcare needs and future retirement security.

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR