A cherished century-old family pizzeria in Coney Island, America’s oldest continuously family-owned, now seeks new owners with no heirs to carry on its legacy amid relentless challenges.
Story Snapshot
- Totonno’s Pizzeria Napolitano, opened in 1924 by Antonio Pero, marks the end of a third-generation family operation due to lack of heirs.
- The historic coal-fired oven and simple menu of pizza with sauce over cheese define its authentic Neapolitan tradition.
- Survived fires, Hurricane Sandy, COVID, and low foot traffic but struggles with weekends-only operation near auto shops.
- Past expansions to Manhattan and Yonkers failed, highlighting sustainability issues for family-run icons.
Historic Roots in Coney Island
Totonno’s Pizzeria Napolitano opened in 1924 when Antonio Pero established the business in Coney Island, New York. This landmark became America’s oldest continuously family-owned pizzeria. Third-generation owners, including Louise “Cookie” and her siblings, maintained operations through dedication. The pizzeria relies on a historic coal-fired oven, central to its authentic Neapolitan pizza preparation. Family stewardship preserved this tradition for a century despite urban changes around it.
Enduring Adversity Over Decades
Fires damaged the property multiple times, testing the family’s resolve. Hurricane Sandy in 2012 flooded the area, disrupting business severely. COVID-19 restrictions further strained weekend-only operations that lack sit-down dining. Low foot traffic near auto shops compounds challenges for its simple menu of pizza and soft drinks only. Owners serve pizza with signature sauce over cheese, adhering to original recipes without adaptation.
Failed Expansions Signal Tough Path
Owners attempted growth by opening locations in Manhattan and Yonkers, but both closed due to operational difficulties. The core Coney Island site sustains on limited hours, reflecting the realities of small family businesses. Simple offerings limit revenue in a competitive market dominated by chains. Location amid industrial areas reduces casual visitors, making daily viability hard without heirs to innovate or invest.
Emotional attachment runs deep for Louise “Cookie” and siblings, who describe letting go as very hard. Yet, readiness emerges after surviving layered crises. No successors exist in the family line, ending direct lineage control.
Hope for New Stewardship
The pizzeria now seeks buyers committed to its legacy. Owners hope new ownership preserves the coal oven and traditions. This transition underscores vulnerabilities of family enterprises without succession plans. In 2025 under President Trump, such stories highlight the value of resilient small businesses against regulatory burdens and economic pressures from past policies. Survival under fresh leadership offers a path forward.
Watch:
Traditional values of family-owned operations face modern hurdles like inflation and shifting neighborhoods. Patriotic Americans cherish these icons as symbols of enduring American spirit and hard work.
